How inflation changes what government collects, and why nobody has to vote on it
We hear it every election cycle. Every candidate makes the same promise: no new taxes. It is an easy promise to keep. The trouble is people’s tax burdens can increase without any new taxes being passed.
Inflation often ends up doing most of the work that a legislative vote used to require.This is what happens when a tax system written in dollars meets a dollar that keeps shrinking in value.
Inflation does two different things to a tax system depending on how it’s written. One is an illusion. The other is real.
The Illusion of Bigger Numbers
Start with sales tax. It’s a percentage of what you spend. If prices rise 4 percent and you buy the same cart of groceries, you pay 4 percent more tax, in dollars that buy 4 percent less. Your real burden hasn’t changed. The trouble starts when those extra dollars are reported, and treated, as new money, as we saw last week with Nevada’s “$1 billion boost.”
Economists call this fiscal illusion, an idea from Amilcare Puviani that James Buchanan developed extensively. When the cost of government is hard to see, people demand more of it. The illusion doesn’t raise your burden today. It raises the spending tomorrow’s taxes will have to cover.
The Real: Fixed Thresholds With Unfixed Dollars
The second effect is quieter and does raise real burdens.
Many taxes have fixed dollar thresholds: a specific dollar amount exemption (“you’re able to write off $1,000”), a set-in-stone floor that you have to go over (“this applies if you made over $3,000,000”), or a bracket edge (“between $150,000 and $300,000”).
These thresholds are helpful because they bring clarity about when a specific rule applies and when it doesn’t. The trouble is when those thresholds aren’t adjusted for inflation. Rising prices can unintentionally push more people and businesses across the thresholds, effectively raising their tax burden, even if nothing about their real situation changed.
Before 1985, this was the famous problem of federal income tax “bracket creep.” A raise that merely kept up with prices could push a household into a higher bracket, so it paid a larger share of its real income in tax. Congress eventually indexed the brackets to inflation. The fix was simple once someone named the problem.
Nevada (thankfully) has no income tax, but it has the same structure elsewhere. For instance, take the Commerce Tax. The Commerce Tax applies only to businesses with Nevada gross revenue above $4 million. That line in the sand was drawn in 2015 and has never moved. $4 million in 2015 is worth roughly $5.7 million today. A business that was comfortably under the line then, and has done nothing but keep pace with prices since, may now be paying a tax it was once exempt from.
No legislator voted to tax that business. Time (and the decisions of Washington D.C.) did.
The Tax Foundation, a nonpartisan tax policy research group, describes the problem precisely in its primer on indexing state tax codes. When thresholds aren’t adjusted for inflation, “the tax code changes without a vote being taken, yielding a lack of political accountability.”
NV lawmakers tried to fix this in 2025. Assembly Bill 276 would have indexed the threshold to inflation going forward. The Legislature’s fiscal staff estimated the cost at about $1.6 million a year, a rounding error in a $12 billion budget, but a potentially meaningful amount for those businesses. Even that modest step showed how much creep had already happened: 145 businesses that paid the tax in 2024 would have owed nothing. The bill failed when the session ended.
It’s worth being clear about what indexing does and doesn’t do. It isn’t a tax cut, and it doesn’t shrink the tax base. It holds the base where the 2015 Legislature put it, in real terms. That’s different from simply raising the line, as a 2023 bill proposing to double it to $8 million would have done.
It’s also the minimum fix, not the ideal one. The Tax Foundation has criticized NV’s Commerce Tax since its passage. Like all gross receipts taxes, it taxes a business’s revenue whether or not it turns a profit, and it compounds at each stage of production. The better long-term answer is a better tax. But until then, indexing at least stops this one’s reach from growing without a vote.
Imbalanced Logic
Here’s the detail that makes things a bit more complicated. Some taxes are levied per unit rather than as a percentage. For example “X cents per gallon”, “Y dollars per pack.” Inflation has the opposite effect and erodes the tax revenue produced from those unless they are moved over time.
Governments notice the revenues falling and are quick to take action. Starting in 2014, Clark County began indexing its fuel tax so it rises automatically with inflation. During the 2025 session, Assembly Bill 530 let the County Commission extend it, and the commission approved another 10 years last November. The reasoning behind the policy rests on the fact that the tax revenue goes to road repairs that get more expensive over time with inflation.
But notice the imbalance in the logic here.
When inflation shrinks revenue, governments index the tax upwards to “close the gap.” When inflation pushes revenue up, or drags new taxpayers in, it gets called growth.
The Tax Foundation’s guidance points to the fix. It recommends that states index consistently, using the same inflation measure across every tax they adjust. That principle cuts both ways. If a state is willing to index the taxes it collects, it should index the lines that decide who pays them.
The Relevant Economic Question
The question citizens usually ask is: did my taxes go up? By that test, the answer is often no. Technically no rates changed. No bills passed.
The relevant economic question is different: did my tax burden increase? Did government’s claim on real resources go up, and did anyone decide that it should?
That question can be answered with three simpler ones, and they work on any budget, in any state:
- Nominal or real? Is this growth in dollars, or growth in what dollars buy, per person served?
- Rate or base? Did someone change the tax, or did the thing being taxed get bigger on its own?
- Voted or automatic? Did a legislature make this choice, or did inflation make it by default?
None of these questions rests on your assumption of whether the government should be bigger or smaller. They just make the cost of the government we have visible. People can disagree about the answer only after they can see what’s being decided.
The Bottom Line
A pledge not to raise taxes is a promise about votes. Inflation, unfortunately, doesn’t care about votes.
The honest version of any tax pledge would add two things: index the fixed thresholds so inflation can’t quietly widen the tax base, and report budgets in inflation-adjusted dollars per resident so nobody mistakes price growth for prosperity.
Neither reform cuts a single program. They just make sure that when the government grows, someone has to explain why and how out loud.
Get the Facts Before the Next Budget
Every session, rising prices get reported as new money. We do the math so you can see what’s really changing and who decided it. Sign up to get our analysis in your inbox.